Have you narrowed down your siding choice to CertainTeed MainStreet or Monogram? Are you now faced with dozens of color options, wondering which will look best on your Indiana home, fade the least, and be worth the upgrade cost?
Choosing the wrong siding color is one of the biggest regrets homeowners have after installation, and it’s expensive to fix. The right color enhances your home’s curb appeal, complements your architectural style, and holds its vibrancy through Indiana’s harsh sun, freeze-thaw cycles, and severe weather. The wrong color clashes with your roof, fades unevenly, or makes your home look dated within a few years.
At Hoel Roofing, we’re CertainTeed 5-Star Certified Contractors who have installed hundreds of CertainTeed siding projects across Indiana. We’ve seen how different colors perform over years of exposure to Indiana’s intense summer sun, winter ice, and spring storms, and we help homeowners choose colors that look great on installation day and stay beautiful for decades.
In this article, we walk you through the MainStreet and Monogram color options, explain which colors work best for Indiana homes, and show you how to choose a color that enhances your home’s long-term value.
By the end, you’ll know which CertainTeed colors are available in your chosen line, which perform best in Indiana weather, and how to coordinate colors with your roof and trim, so you can make a confident color decision before scheduling installation.
| Feature | MainStreet | Monogram |
| Total Colors | 25 | 38+ |
| Standard Colors | 21 | 30+ |
| Premium Colors | 4 | 8+ |
| Multi-Tone Blends | No | Yes (7+ blend options) |
| Wood-Look Finishes | Basic woodgrain | TrueTexture™ deep cedar grain |
| Fade Resistance | PermaColor™ standard | PermaColor™ enhanced |
MainStreet offers a curated palette of classic, timeless colors. It is the most common choice for Indiana homeowners who want a clean, brushed, or woodgrain finish without the premium price tag.
Available Palettes:
Monogram is CertainTeed’s flagship vinyl siding. It includes all MainStreet colors plus exclusive multi-tone blends that mimic the look of real stained cedar.
All MainStreet colors PLUS:
Exclusive Premium Blends:
Monogram Exclusive Colors:
In Indiana, south-facing walls bear the brunt of the sun. While all CertainTeed products feature PermaColor™ Lifetime Fade Protection, the vibrancy of your color depends on the shade you choose.
The colors with the best fade resistance are:
These colors have high fade resistance because they reflect UV rays rather than absorbing them
Colors with higher fade risk are:
The #1 mistake is choosing siding without looking at your roof. Here are our 2026 coordination rules:
Traditional/Colonial Homes:
Ranch/Mid-Century Homes:
Craftsman/Bungalow Homes:
Farmhouse/Country Homes:
Modern/Contemporary Homes:
When Premium Colors Are Worth It:
When Standard Colors Are Fine:
25 colors (21 standard, 4 premium).
38+ colors (30+ standard, 8+ premium), including exclusive multi-tone blends.
Light colors (Colonial White, Snow, Heritage Cream, Sterling Gray) and Monogram premium blends (Cedar, Weathered, Natural).
Colonial White. It is timeless, excellent fade resistance, and complements all styles.
Yes. Add $0.50–$1.50 per sq ft ($1,000–$3,000 for a 2,000 sq ft home).
MainStreet: 20-35 years; Monogram: 25-40+ years (varies by color and sun exposure).
Yes, darker colors show dirt, dust, and pollen more visibly than light colors. However, CertainTeed’s PermaColor™ technology resists fading and chalking, so regular cleaning keeps dark colors vibrant.
Use a soft brush or soft-wash method (low-pressure spray) with mild detergent and water. For stubborn stains, use a mixture of equal parts white vinegar and water, or a manufacturer-approved vinyl siding cleaner. Rinse thoroughly with a garden hose.
Quality vinyl siding like CertainTeed MainStreet and Monogram is engineered to resist warping in Indiana’s extreme heat (90°F+ summers). However, improper installation (too-tight fastening, inadequate ventilation gaps) can cause warping.
Step 1: Start with your roof color – It dictates compatible siding options
Step 2: Match your home’s architectural style – Use the style guide above
Step 3: Consider your neighborhood – Stand out without sticking out
Step 4: Plan trim and accent colors – Ensure siding, trim, doors, and shutters work together
Step 5: View samples in natural light – Never choose from a screen; see 12″x12″ samples against your home at different times of day
CertainTeed MainStreet offers 25 timeless colors perfect for traditional styles and budget-conscious homeowners, while Monogram’s 38+ colors include premium blends, bolder tones, and superior fade resistance for homeowners prioritizing long-term curb appeal.
Color selection is one of the most important decisions you’ll make, and one of the hardest to change later. Your next step is to narrow your choices to 3–5 colors based on your home’s architectural style and roof color, then schedule a consultation to view physical samples against your home in natural light.
At Hoel Roofing, we’re CertainTeed 5-Star Certified Contractors who have installed hundreds of MainStreet and Monogram siding projects across Indiana. Use our Free Instant Estimate to find out how much your siding replacement will cost.
Your siding color is a decades-long decision. Let’s make sure you get it right the first time.
Bob Hoel is the owner and founder of Hoel Roofing & Remodeling, proudly serving Rushville, IN, and surrounding areas with high-quality roofing and remodeling services for over 9 years. With decades of hands-on experience in residential and commercial roofing, Bob specializes in installing and repairing asphalt shingles, metal roofing, and custom exterior solutions. He is committed to staying current with the latest roofing technologies and best practices. As both a contractor and an educator, Bob is dedicated to helping homeowners understand roofing systems, maintenance, and how to protect one of their biggest investments: their home.
