Who Are the Best Roofing Companies in East Central Indiana?
If you’re searching for the best roofing company in East Central Indiana, chances are you’re either dealing with a roofing issue right now—or you’re being proactive before a bigger one develops. Whether it’s storm damage, age-related wear, or a surprise leak, we know this isn’t a small decision. Choosing the right roofing company matters.
In this article, we’ll walk you through what to look for in a roofing contractor, what makes a company trustworthy, and we’ll even list out a few of the top roofing companies in the region—including ourselves, Hoel Roofing. But we’ll be upfront: we’re not the best fit for everyone, and we’ll tell you who might be a better option depending on your needs.
Let’s start with why you’re here.
Why You Might Be Searching for the Best Roofing Company
Signs It’s Time to Replace or Repair Your Roof
If you’re reading this, it’s likely because you’ve noticed one or more of the following issues:
Missing or damaged shingles
Water leaks in your attic or ceiling
Curling or cracked shingles
Stains on interior walls or ceilings
Recent hail, wind, or storm activity in your area
Granules from shingles collecting in your gutters
You’re planning to sell or buy a home and were advised about roof condition
These signs may indicate that your roof is at the end of its life—or that it simply needs professional attention.
What Most Homeowners Care About When Choosing a Roofer
Based on the conversations we’ve had with hundreds of local homeowners, here’s what typically matters most:
Trustworthiness: Is this a company that does what it says?
Warranty: What happens if something goes wrong a few years down the line?
Cost: Am I getting a fair, transparent quote?
Experience: Have they done a roof like yours before? Are they respected locally?
Why It’s Smart to Compare Companies Before Requesting Quotes
We always recommend that homeowners compare multiple roofing companies. Not because you should go with the cheapest quote—but because comparison helps you spot red flags, build confidence, and make sure you’re hiring someone that will provide a roof that you’ll feel good about for the next 20+ years.
What Makes a Roofing Company “The Best”?
It’s not about who has the flashiest trucks or the biggest billboard. It’s about who delivers real value and protection for your home.
Licensing, Insurance, and Credentials
Any roofing company you consider should be:
Properly licensed in the state of Indiana
Fully insured with general liability and workers’ comp
Certified by major shingle manufacturers like GAF or Owens Corning
Local Reputation and Reviews
Look for a roofer with strong Google reviews, a consistent track record, and recent customer testimonials. Ask your neighbors who they used. A company that’s done good work locally will have a trail of satisfied customers.
Clear Communication and Education
You deserve a roofer who helps you understand your options—not one who confuses you or uses high-pressure tactics. The best roofers make the process clear, give you honest answers, and explain why they recommend what they do.
Warranty Coverage (Workmanship and Materials)
A quality roofing company should offer both:
A material warranty (typically backed by the manufacturer)
A workmanship warranty (covered by the installer)
Make sure you know who covers what—and for how long.
Experience With Your Type of Roof or Project
From asphalt shingle roofs to metal roofs, steep pitches to low slopes—make sure the roofer has done jobs like yours before. Ask for photos or references.
Responsiveness and Reliability
Do they call back quickly? Show up when they say they will? Keep you updated throughout the process? These things may seem small—until something goes wrong and communication becomes everything.
Best Roofing Companies in East Central Indiana
Below is an unbiased list of roofing companies in our region that homeowners often consider. We’ve included ourselves last, but not because we think we’re the only great option.
1. Cochran Exteriors
Service Area: Muncie and surrounding areas
Years in Business: 10+
Roof Types: Asphalt shingles, metal roofing, siding, gutters
What They’re Known For: A well-known regional contractor with strong manufacturer certifications and financing options.
2. Richmond Exteriors
Service Area: Greater Indianapolis and Eastern Indiana
What They’re Known For: Family-owned company with a long local track record and broad service offering.
3. Bone Dry Roofing
Service Area: Central and East Indiana
Years in Business: 35+
Roof Types: Asphalt shingles, insulation, gutters
What They’re Known For: Nationally recognized with strong warranties and a full-service home exterior model.
4. Hoel Roofing
Service Area: East Central Indiana
Years in Business: 20+
Roof Types: Asphalt shingles, metal roofing
What We’re Known For: Straightforward communication, no high-pressure sales, and a focus on educating homeowners. We’re a good fit for homeowners looking for a transparent, no-nonsense roofing experience.
Who We’re Not a Fit For: If you’re looking for the lowest-cost option or a company that can do siding and windows, we may not be the best fit—we specialize in roofing only.
How to Choose the Right Roofing Company for Your Needs
Questions to Ask During the Sales Process
What kind of warranty do you offer?
Are you licensed and insured?
Will you be the ones installing the roof, or do you use subcontractors?
How long will the project take?
Red Flags to Watch Out For
High-pressure sales or “today-only” discounts
Vague or confusing estimates
No recent reviews or online presence
No proof of insurance or license
How to Compare Quotes Fairly
Don’t just compare final price—compare:
What materials are being used?
How many nails per shingle?
Are underlayment and ventilation included?
What’s the warranty coverage?
Common Questions About Hiring a Roofing Company
How Much Should a New Roof Cost in East Central Indiana?
Most asphalt shingle roofs in this region cost between $8,000 and $18,000 depending on the size and complexity of the job. Metal roofs and steep-pitched roofs may cost more. Always ask for a detailed quote.
How Long Does Roof Installation Usually Take?
Most residential roofs take 1–2 days to complete, weather permitting.
What Warranties Should I Expect?
Look for:
Material warranty: 25–50 years, typically offered by the manufacturer
Workmanship warranty: 5–25 years, offered by the contractor
Can I Finance My Roof Replacement?
Yes. Many roofing companies—including us at Hoel Roofing—offer financing options through trusted partners.
Final Thoughts: Choosing a Roofing Company You Can Trust
Finding the right roofer in East Central Indiana isn’t easy—but it’s worth the effort. By asking the right questions, looking beyond just price, and choosing someone who communicates clearly and works with integrity, you’ll set yourself up for success.
If you have questions—not just about quotes, but about your roof in general—we’re happy to help. Reach out to Hoel Roofing any time for honest answers, detailed explanations, and a roofing experience that respects your time and your home. You can reach us through our website at www.hoelrr.com
