If you’re looking for a roofing company you can trust in Columbus, IN, you’re not alone.
Roof replacements and repairs are big investments. They protect your home, boost its value, and give you peace of mind, but only if the job’s done right. That’s why choosing the right roofer matters just as much as choosing the right shingles.
At Hoel Roofing, we’ve been serving East Central Indiana for over 9 years, helping homeowners find roofing solutions that last. We’ve seen great workmanship and, unfortunately, some costly mistakes, so we know what separates reliable contractors from risky ones.
In this article, we’ll walk you through what to look for in a Columbus roofing contractor and what makes a company trustworthy. We’ll even list out a few of the top roofing companies in Columbus, including ourselves, Hoel Roofing. But we’ll be upfront: we’re not the best fit for everyone, and we’ll tell you who might be a better option depending on your needs.
When it comes to picking the best roofers in Columbus, Indiana, we wanted this list to be helpful, not competitive. Every company here has earned its spot through a combination of proven experience, trusted reviews, and community impact.
Here’s what we looked for:
Each of these Columbus roofing contractors embodies these values, so homeowners can choose confidently knowing their roof is in capable hands.
Below is an unbiased list of roofing companies in our region that homeowners often consider. The companies listed below are not ranked in any way – we’ve put them in alphabetical order to reduce any perceived bias.
DC Roofing & Exteriors offers a comprehensive range of exterior services, including roofing, siding, windows, and gutters. They’re known for responsive customer support and quality-driven craftsmanship, making them a reliable one-stop shop for homeowners looking to update or restore their home’s exterior. Licensed, insured, and locally owned, they’ve built a strong reputation in their 10+ years of business.
With 9+ years of experience in the Columbus area, Hoel Roofing is known for clear communication, skilled craftsmanship, and flexible financing options through Slice Financing. Their detailed, no-pressure estimates and verified Google reviews make them a standout for homeowners who value trust and transparency. We specialize in roofing, windows, doors, siding, and gutters.
Koontz Roofing is a locally owned company with deep community roots in Columbus. They emphasize one-on-one service, straightforward communication, and lasting quality. With over 20 years in business, they specialize in roofing, skylights, windows, siding, and gutter replacements. Whether it’s repairing storm damage or installing a new roof, Koontz is certified and insured.
A locally trusted roofing company, Moore’s Roofing specializes in residential roofing (Asphalt & Metal), light commercial roofing, and seamless gutter services. Customers often highlight their honest estimates and clean job sites. With 10+ years in business, verified reviews, and full insurance, Moore’s Roofing is a dependable choice for Columbus homeowners.
RS Warren Construction offers a diverse range of construction and roofing services, making them a versatile choice for both homeowners and small businesses. With 30+ years of business, they’re known for dependable project management, licensed crews, and clear communication, ensuring every roofing job is completed safely and efficiently. Their positive Google reviews reflect their consistent quality and customer-first approach.
South Central Roofing stands out for its experience handling both residential and commercial projects, including metal roofing and full tear-offs. Known for strong warranties and high-quality materials, they’ve earned excellent feedback for their professionalism and reliability in their 10+ years of operation. They are also licensed and insured.
Choosing the right roofing company can make the difference between a smooth, long-lasting roof installation and a stressful, costly experience. Whether you need a full replacement, repairs, or maintenance, the goal is to find a roofer who is trustworthy, transparent, and skilled.
Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you make an informed decision.
Begin by looking up local roofing companies with solid reputations. Read Google reviews, check their ratings, and visit their websites.
When researching, aim to compare at least three companies to get a fair sense of pricing and professionalism.
Asking the right questions helps you understand what to expect and spot red flags early. Here are essential questions to ask before signing any contract:
A trustworthy roofer should offer both a manufacturer’s warranty (for materials) and a workmanship warranty (for installation).
Always verify their state license and request proof of liability and workers’ compensation insurance. This protects you if an accident occurs.
Some companies hire outside crews, which can affect quality and accountability. If subcontractors are used, ensure they’re also licensed and insured.
The timeline depends on roof size, material, and weather, but a professional should give you a clear estimate with start and completion dates.
Reputable companies often have a portfolio or references from past clients. Ask for addresses of recent projects or photos for comparison.
Some signs indicate a roofer may not be reliable. Keep an eye out for these common red flags:
It’s best to get at least three estimates from reputable local contractors. This helps you compare pricing, warranties, and professionalism.
Most states have an online database where you can search for active contractor licenses. You can also ask the roofer directly for their license number and verify it.
Not always. The lowest bid can sometimes mean cutting corners or using low-quality materials. Focus on value, reputation, and warranty coverage, not just cost.
A manufacturer’s warranty covers roofing materials (such as shingles) against defects. A workmanship warranty covers errors made during installation.
Spring and fall are typically ideal because of mild weather. However, many experienced roofers work year-round and can adapt to seasonal conditions.
Clear your driveway for materials delivery, remove fragile items from walls (vibrations can occur), and cover attic belongings to protect them from dust.
Roofing has, unfortunately, earned a mixed reputation because of a few bad actors. To protect yourself from scams, be sure to:
If you’re confused about what you need to ask your roofer, check out our article How Do I Know If I’m Hiring the Right Indiana Roofer? 7 Questions to Ask First
Toyosi Ogunsola is the Content Manager at Hoel Roofing & Remodeling in Rushville, IN, where she oversees the creation of educational, trustworthy content about roofing, remodeling, and home improvement. With a master’s degree in Emerging Media Design and Development and a background spanning content strategy, UX research, and digital marketing, Toyosi combines data-driven insights with clear, engaging writing to help homeowners make informed decisions. Passionate about translating complex roofing topics into helpful resources, she works closely with Hoel’s team of roofing experts to ensure every piece of content is accurate, practical, and user-focused.
