When it’s time to replace your roof or choose one for a new home or commercial building, few decisions feel as big as picking the right roofing material. Among the top contenders are asphalt shingles, metal roofing, and flat roofing systems.
Each has its advantages, costs, and ideal applications, and choosing the wrong one could mean headaches, higher expenses, or a roof that simply doesn’t suit your property’s style or function.
So, how do you decide?
At Hoel Roofing, we’ve worked with homeowners across Indiana, from first-time buyers to long-term homeowners, and guided them in making the right roofing choice. Let’s compare these popular options head-to-head across the most important factors homeowners and property managers care about: cost, appearance, durability, maintenance, energy efficiency, and return on investment (ROI).
Comparing The Cost Of Asphalt Shingles and Metal Roofs
Asphalt Shingles are the most budget-friendly choice. On average, asphalt shingles cost between $4.50 and $7.50 per square foot installed, depending on quality and region. This makes them a go-to for homeowners seeking an affordable solution without sacrificing protection.
Metal Roofing carries a higher upfront price, typically ranging from $8 to $14 per square foot installed for standing seam panels or premium metals like aluminium and copper. While more expensive initially, metal roofs can last significantly longer, potentially saving money over time.
Asphalt shingles are a great fit for homeowners who want a clean, classic look that works with just about any home style. Whether you’ve got a ranch, colonial, or craftsman-style house, asphalt shingles offer enough color and style variety to blend in-or stand out-without breaking the budget. They’re especially well-suited for neighborhoods where affordability, durability, and curb appeal all matter.
Metal roofing is a strong choice for homeowners who want a sleek, modern look, or who love the charm of farmhouse, rustic, or industrial styles. It pairs well with contemporary architecture, cabins, and country-style homes, but it’s also showing up more in traditional neighborhoods thanks to its clean lines and bold presence. If you’re aiming for a roof that makes a statement and complements more distinctive home designs, metal is a great fit.
Asphalt Shingles have a lifespan of 15-30 years, depending on the quality of the shingles and climate conditions. Severe weather, such as hail or strong winds, can significantly reduce their lifespan. Most roofing shingles come with a basic limited lifetime warranty, which is the industry standard.
Metal Roofing is highly durable and can last 40-70 years. It resists cracking, shrinking, and erosion. Metal also handles harsh weather well, shedding rain and snow effectively. However, dents from hail or fallen branches are possible with softer metals like aluminium.
Asphalt Shingles require periodic inspections to catch curling, cracking, or missing shingles. Repairs are relatively inexpensive and straightforward.
Metal Roofing is low-maintenance but should be inspected for fastener issues, sealant wear, and dents. Repairs can be more specialized and sometimes pricier than asphalt shingle repairs.
Asphalt Shingles can reflect some solar heat, especially “cool roof” versions (specially designed to reflect the sun’s energy and absorb less heat than standard shingles), but overall, they absorb more heat than metal or certain flat roof membranes, consequently, asphalt is the least energy-efficient option of the three.
Metal Roofs works great for energy efficiency. They reflect a large portion of the sun’s rays instead of absorbing them, keeping your home cooler and reducing the strain on your AC. Light-colored or specially coated metal roofs can enhance this effect even further.
Asphalt Shingles offer a solid ROI, especially if you choose architectural shingles, which can boost curb appeal and resale value. However, because they require more frequent replacement, their long-term ROI is lower than that of more durable options.
Metal Roofing can recoup 60-85% of its cost in resale value and offers long-term savings thanks to durability and energy efficiency. Many buyers appreciate its modern look and longevity.
The “best” roof ultimately depends on your budget, design preferences, and long-term goals.
Not sure which one fits your property best? Contact Hoel Roofing today for a free consultation and personalized quote. We’ll help you make a choice that protects your investment for years to come.
Toyosi Ogunsola is the Content Manager at Hoel Roofing & Remodeling in Rushville, IN, where she oversees the creation of educational, trustworthy content about roofing, remodeling, and home improvement. With a master’s degree in Emerging Media Design and Development and a background spanning content strategy, UX research, and digital marketing, Toyosi combines data-driven insights with clear, engaging writing to help homeowners make informed decisions. Passionate about translating complex roofing topics into helpful resources, she works closely with Hoel’s team of roofing experts to ensure every piece of content is accurate, practical, and user-focused.
